Brand Autopsies

Google+ Brand Autopsy: What Really Killed Google+?

Google+ brand autopsy

Google+ launched in 2011 to fight Facebook, was forced into YouTube and Gmail, then shut in April 2019 after a data leak. Why didn't people stick around?

Google+ might be the only social network that millions of people joined without ever meaning to.

If you had a Gmail account or left a YouTube comment in the early 2010s, you probably had a Google+ profile. And yet, when it shut down in 2019, very few people noticed it was gone.

The Brand, Before Everything Went Wrong

By 2011, Facebook had hundreds of millions of users and was becoming a serious threat to Google. People were spending more time on Facebook, sharing links there instead of searching, and advertisers were following them.

Google had tried social products before, including Orkut, which was popular in Brazil and India, and Google Buzz, which launched in 2010 and quickly ran into privacy criticism. Neither made a dent in Facebook’s dominance.

In June 2011, Google launched Google+. It was led by Vic Gundotra, a senior executive, and it was a huge company priority. Employees’ bonuses were reportedly linked to the success of Google’s social efforts.

Google+ had some genuinely good ideas. “Circles” let you share different things with different groups of people, such as friends, family and colleagues. “Hangouts” offered free group video chat, years before video calls were common. Reviewers liked the clean design.

At launch, Google+ was invite-only, which created buzz. Within weeks, it had tens of millions of users. For a moment, it looked like Google might actually challenge Facebook.

There was also a branding problem. Google already had many products with overlapping purposes. Google+ was meant to tie them together, but for users it often felt like another login screen and another profile to manage. Instead of simplifying Google, it made it feel more complicated.

What Actually Happened

Signing up was one thing. Staying was another.

Most people’s friends were already on Facebook. Google+ had nice features, but it didn’t give people a strong reason to move their social life. Many users signed up, looked around and never came back.

Google responded by pushing Google+ into its other products. Creating a Gmail account often meant creating a Google+ profile. In November 2013, Google required people to use Google+ accounts to comment on YouTube.

Millions of YouTube users were furious, and a petition against the change gathered huge support. Even YouTube’s co-founder publicly complained.

Google also initially required people to use their real names on Google+, which caused another backlash, especially from people who had good reasons to be anonymous. Google later dropped the rule.

Google reported impressive headline numbers, often counting anyone who used a Google+ feature, like the +1 button, across Google’s services. But independent measures suggested people spent very little time on Google+ itself compared with Facebook.

In April 2014, Vic Gundotra left Google. Soon after, Google began separating Google+ from its other products. Photos and Hangouts were split off into standalone apps.

In October 2018, Google revealed that a software bug had exposed private profile data of up to 500,000 Google+ users. It said it had found the bug earlier in the year and decided not to disclose it at the time. Google announced it would shut down Google+ for consumers.

A second bug, affecting millions more, sped up the closure. Google+ shut down on April 2, 2019.

The backlash was loud and public. Popular YouTubers made videos criticising the change. Comment sections filled with complaints about Google+.

Some users deliberately posted protest messages through their new Google+ accounts. For many younger internet users, this was their main experience of Google+, and it was entirely negative.

The move also changed the tone of YouTube comments in ways Google hadn’t intended. Instead of improving conversations, the integration created confusion and anger. Within about two years, Google reversed course and removed the requirement.

By then, the Google+ brand was deeply unpopular. Internally, the social strategy began to wind down. Google focused on products that stood on their own, like Photos, which was spun out of Google+ in 2015.

Honestly, it’s hard to think of a clearer example of a company confusing its goals with its customers’ goals. Google wanted more people using Google+. YouTube commenters wanted to comment on videos. Those two things were never the same.

The Moment of No Return

The moment was November 2013, when Google forced Google+ onto YouTube comments.

It revealed the truth about Google+. People weren’t choosing it. They were being pushed into it.

And when you force a product on people, they don’t just resist. They resent it.

After that, Google+ became a symbol of corporate strategy trumping user choice. Every attempt to boost its numbers by tying it to other services made the brand less popular.

Google’s own culture didn’t help. It was a company built on engineering and search, where data and algorithms were more natural than community and social dynamics. Building a social network required a different kind of thinking, about people’s relationships and habits. Google had brilliant engineers, but that wasn’t the same as understanding why people share.

What Everyone Got Wrong About Why It Failed

The standard explanation is that Facebook already had everyone’s friends, so Google+ never stood a chance.

That’s a big part of it. But I’d argue the deeper problem was that Google+ was built to solve Google’s problem, not the user’s.

Google needed social data, real identities and a way to keep people in its ecosystem. Those were valid business needs. But users didn’t have a problem that Google+ solved better than Facebook. Circles and Hangouts were clever, but they weren’t enough reason to move.

Look at what survived. Google Photos and Google Meet, which grew from Hangouts, became hugely successful when they stood on their own and solved a clear problem. The technology was good. The social network wrapped around it wasn’t needed.

The timeline is telling. Google+ launched with enormous investment and company-wide priority in 2011. Within three years its leader had left, and within eight years it was gone. Even one of the world’s most powerful technology companies couldn’t force a social network into existence.

The data bug was the final straw, but it wasn’t the cause. By 2018, Google+ was already a ghost town, and the bug simply gave Google a reason to close it.

The Numbers That Tell the Story

June 2011: the month Google+ launched.

November 2013: when Google required a Google+ account to comment on YouTube.

Up to 500,000: the number of users whose private profile data was exposed by the bug revealed in October 2018.

April 2, 2019: the day Google+ shut down for consumers.

What Marketers Can Learn

First, build for your customer’s problem, not your company’s. Google+ solved Google’s need for social data but not users’ need for a better social network. The most memorable iconic marketing campaigns start with what the customer actually wants.

Second, forcing adoption breeds resentment. Tying Google+ to YouTube and Gmail boosted numbers and destroyed goodwill. Earn your customers; don’t trap them.

Third, don’t confuse sign-ups with success. Google+ had impressive user counts and very little real engagement. Classic marketing frameworks that focus on retention and activation exist because vanity metrics can hide a failing product.

Google+ had millions of members. What it never had was a reason for them to stay.

Brand Strategy

Protecting your positioning and market share as you scale? Let's talk through your strategy before rolling out major changes.

Schedule a consultation

More Brand Autopsies